Engineering 175 · two casts, 8 sec + 8 sec · 225 crafts an hour · sell to any vendor
7s00c a craft
2 dynamite × 3s50c · not yet seen in game
Price through the day · average cost each for 200 stone and 100 silk · by hour, Central time
Solid Stone Silk Cloth Hover the chart for an hour's prices.
Middle price for each hour. 49 hourly saves over about 2 days (Nov 15 to Nov 17), so one to three saves an hour: a first look. Stone is cheapest about 8pm to 1am and near 7am. The 2am spike is one save (Nov 17), when the cheap stone was gone. Silk hardly moves.
Recipe, one craft Wowhead ForeverAPI
Use
Makes
Cast
2 Solid Stone
1 Solid Blasting Powder
8 sec
1 powder + 1 Silk Cloth
2 Solid Dynamite
8 sec
Both sources agree: makes 2. No tools. Train both at 175, 10s each. Stacks to 20. Not yet seen in game.
Sum rule: 2 stone + 1 silk
Cost
Profit a craft
Do
Under 5s00c
over 2s
Buy
5s00c to 6s00c
1s to 2s
Thin
Over 6s00c
under 1s
Wait
Break-even: 7s00c. Mats at 7s00c make nothing.
Price bands · average price to fill 200 stone and 100 silk · 49 hourly saves measured
Lowest
Usual low
Middle
Usual high
Highest
Solid Stone
1s08c
1s32c
1s43c
1s59c
5s44c
Silk Cloth
1s64c
1s93c
1s96c
1s98c
2s00c
Profit a craft
-5s79c
1s96c
2s24c
2s39c
2s89c
Profit of 2s or more in 35 of 49 saves · 1s50c or more in 44 · 1s or more in 48 · a loss in 1 (Nov 17, 2am)
Profit a craft at each buy point (7s00c minus 2 stone minus 1 silk)
Stone ↓ / Silk →
1s65c
1s85c
1s95c
2s00c
2s20c
1s10c
3s15c
2s95c
2s85c
2s80c
2s60c
1s20c
2s95c
2s75c
2s65c
2s60c
2s40c
1s30c
2s75c
2s55c
2s45c
2s40c
2s20c
1s45c
2s45c
2s25c
2s15c
2s10c
1s90c
1s60c
2s15c
1s95c
1s85c
1s80c
1s60c
1s80c
1s75c
1s55c
1s45c
1s40c
1s20c
2s00c
1s35c
1s15c
1s05c
1s00c
80c
2s50c
35c
15c
5c
0c
-20c
Gold per crafting hour at each buy point (225 crafts an hour, 16 sec a craft)
Stone ↓ / Silk →
1s65c
1s85c
1s95c
2s00c
2s20c
1s10c
7g08s
6g63s
6g41s
6g30s
5g85s
1s20c
6g63s
6g18s
5g96s
5g85s
5g40s
1s30c
6g18s
5g73s
5g51s
5g40s
4g95s
1s45c
5g51s
5g06s
4g83s
4g72s
4g27s
1s60c
4g83s
4g38s
4g16s
4g05s
3g60s
1s80c
3g93s
3g48s
3g26s
3g15s
2g70s
2s00c
3g03s
2g58s
2g36s
2g25s
1g80s
2s50c
0g78s
0g33s
0g11s
0g00s
-0g45s
This is casting time only. Buying and vendor trips are extra. At middle prices: 4g90s50c an hour.
Depth · how many paying crafts the book holds measured
Paying crafts
1st
100th
500th
1,000th
Now (Nov 17, 5:25pm)
3,255
4s96c
5s00c
5s06c
5s26c
Middle hour
2,201
4s69c
4s90c
5s02c
5s30c
The last four columns are the mats cost of that craft as you buy up the book. The book reached 1,000 crafts in 43 of 49 saves. Profit in the whole book: 50g03s54c now, 32g72s27c in the middle hour. The harness holds 285 paying crafts in its middle hour (64 now); Raptor Hide is its limit. This book is about 8 times deeper.
Batch at middle prices (4s82c a craft)
Crafts
Stone + silk
Cost
Vendor
Profit
Casting
50
100 + 50
2g41s00c
3g50s00c
1g09s00c
13 min
100
200 + 100
4g82s00c
7g00s00c
2g18s00c
27 min
250
500 + 250
12g05s00c
17g50s00c
5g45s00c
67 min
500
1000 + 500
24g10s00c
35g00s00c
10g90s00c
133 min
Big batches cost a little more: see Depth.
Limits
Stone
Silk
Good buy
to 1s50c
to 2s00c
Stop here
2s00c
2s00c
Break-even
2s52c
4s14c
Break-even assumes the other one sits at its middle price.
Rules
1. Craft one first. Check for 2 dynamite and 3s50c each.
2. Vendor the same session. Never hold dynamite.
3. Stone is the one that jumps. Over 2s00c, wait an hour.
4. Buy one price step at a time.
Skill gain: yellow 175 · green 185 · grey 195
Risks
1. Needs Engineering 175. Not trained yet.
2. Never made in game. The first craft must make 2.
3. The vendor price could be patched. Iron Grenade was cut on Nov 10.
4. Silk has a floor. Silk Bandage vendors for 2s00c, raw silk for 1s50c. It will not get much cheaper.
5. Bags: 100 crafts is 15 slots of mats and 10 of dynamite.
6. Your own buying lifts the price.
House 114, Horde. Saves from Sun Nov 15 4:17 pm to Tue Nov 17 5:25 pm CST. Last save: stone 1s50c, silk 1s96c, profit 2s03c a craft. Recipe, casts, skill: Wowhead Forever. Vendor price and yield: Wowhead Forever and Blizzard API. Getting to 175: see the card "Engineering 1 to 175: cheapest path".